In the Lab’s lip treatment test, this balm scored the highest out of all the contenders. Testers found that it made their lips appear smooth and full almost immediately after application. “I liked everything about this product,” says one tester. “I would continue using it because it would be replacing three of my products. It was a great anti-ager. I saw noticeable results within 10 days. Also was a very good lip plumper.”

While it’s the least expensive option on the list, this e.l.f. gloss works just as well as some pricier options. The plumping effect is a bit more subtle, but it does help to create fullness and smooth lines. Reviewers say that the tingling sensation can feel a bit intense, but the feeling goes away quickly. 

Exfoliation is a major key to plush, full lips that’s often overlooked. That’s why GH’s Beauty Director April Franzino opts for a product that incorporates it. “This dual-ended lip treatment from Jane Iredale has a brown sugar lip scrub on one end to exfoliate and sheer pink tinted balm on the other end that contains ginger and mint—I love how plush my lips looked and felt after use,” she says. 

For an impossibly shimmery and alluring finish, snag one of the many shades of this plumping lip gloss. “This is one of those products that I buy over and over again,” says Danusia Wnek, chemist at the Good Housekeeping Institute. “It is a thick but not too sticky or tacky gloss that gives shine and ever so subtly temporarily plumps lips. This one does tingle on the lips a bit, which I like. I love that they have so many different shades and the crème variant is also really nice. It’s my go to lip gloss!”

Yes, it may seem like a lot to pay for a lip treatment, but as a GH Beauty Lab test winner, this fast-absorbing, non-sticky VenEffect balm is worth it. Packed full of nourishing ingredients like peptides and antioxidants, the Lab evaluated that it made lips look fuller after four weeks of use. “It made my lips feel soft and smooth and appear fuller,” a tester said. 

For gloss with a high color payoff and a long-lasting plumping effect, look no further than this Dior lacquer. “As I get older, I see my lips aren’t as full as they used to be and this brings my lips back 10 years,” says one reviewer. “It makes them look slightly fuller and younger. It has a great feel, not heavy and last for hours.“

Chock full of peptides, hyaluronic acid and ceramides, this clinically-tested lip plumper helps volumize and hydrate your pout. “It does tingle but I must say my lips plumped up and the shape was not lost,” says one reviewer. “They looked healthy and rosy and felt marvelously moist.”

This product has been around for years — and for good reason. “I always come back to DuWop lip venom, I have tried other plumping products and this one for me is the best,” says one reviewer. “My lips are already on the fuller side but I love the look this product gives me. Plumps my pout and I don’t mind the tingles because I feel like that means it’s working.”

This super-light, non-sticky gloss glides on easily and delivers a plumping effect. “It is indeed plumping, and there was no unpleasant scent or stinging,” says one reviewer. “The color is very soft and not very bright.”

Lawless’s new lip gloss smells like spun sugar and tingles slightly when you slick it on your lips. This reflective, faintly pink gloss seemingly erases any trace of lines on the lips. Wear it over your favorite lip color or on its own — just keep in mind, the thicker formula is a bit stickier than some. 

If your lips are in need of a major hydration boost, this is the perfect quick fix. This lightweight balm smells sweet and minty and delivers a mellow cooling sensation. The non-sticky formula glides easily onto lips and leaves a slight shine, instantly plumping your pout. Bonus? It even tastes good. 

This lip sleeping mask is a cult favorite — and for good reason. Smooth this on before you go to sleep and wake up with impossibly plump lips. It smells like candy (they even have a gummy bear flavor), and it goes on thick without being sticky or gloopy.

Instead of a gloss, this lip plumper comes in an innovative gel form. Even more intriguing? The vegan formula employs Sichuan pepper to help plump lips (and deliver a tingle!). “I put some on overnight and my lips look really good [in the] morning, not to mention I can still feel it on my lips,” says one reviewer. “It seems to be very moisturizing.” 

Okay, it’s not technically a lip plumper, but this sheer cream does double-duty for both eyes and lips. Not only does it help plump the area around your eyes (erasing dark circles), it also plumps up your lips. The lightweight formula sinks in almost instantly, creating an instant fullness effect and making the perfect canvas for your favorite lip product to go on top. 

If extreme plumping is your goal, this treatment will do the trick. Reviewers say this gloss really works to make their lips appear fuller, but the effect is intense — your lips may experience a burning sensation.